| Player | No. | Year | Club | Nation | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aaron Lennon | 25 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Aaron Wan-Bissaka | 29 | 2023 | Manchester United | England | |
| Alan Bloor | 6 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| Alan Deakin | 6 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Alan Deakin | 6 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Alan Gilzean | 7 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland | |
| Alan Gilzean | 7 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland | |
| Alan Hansen | 6 | 1981 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Alan Hansen | 6 | 1981 R | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Alan Hansen | 6 | 1983 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Alan Hansen | 6 | 1984 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Alan Hansen | 6 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Alan Hutton | 28 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland | |
| Alan Judge | 1 | 1986 | Oxford United | England | |
| Alan Kennedy | 3 | 1981 | Liverpool | England | |
| Alan Kennedy | 3 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Alan Kennedy | 4 | 1982 | Liverpool | England | |
| Alan Kennedy | 3 | 1983 | Liverpool | England | |
| Alan Kennedy | 3 | 1984 | Liverpool | England | |
| Alan Kennedy | 3 | 1984 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Alan Mahon | 16 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | Republic of Ireland | |
| Alan Miller | 27 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | England | |
| Alan Mullery (c) | 4 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Alan Oakes | 6 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Alan Oakes | 6 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Alan O'Neill | 8 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Alan Smith | 9 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Alan Sunderland | 7 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Alan Wright | 3 | 1996 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Alec Chamberlain | 28 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| Alejandro Garnacho | 49 | 2023 | Manchester United | Argentina | |
| Aleksandar Kolarov | 13 | 2014 | Manchester City | Serbia | |
| Aleksandar Kolarov | 11 | 2016 | Manchester City | Serbia | |
| Alex Cropley | 10 | 1977 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Alex Cropley | 10 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain | 15 | 2022 | Liverpool | England | |
| Alisson | 1 | 2022 | Liverpool | Brazil | |
| Allan Nielsen | 6 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | Denmark | |
| Allan Young | 5 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | England | |
| Alun Evans | 12 | 1975 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Álvaro Negredo | 9 | 2014 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| Ander Herrera | 21 | 2017 | Manchester United | Spain | |
| Anderson | 8 | 2009 | Manchester United | Brazil | |
| Andrei Kanchelskis | 7 | 1992 | Manchester United | Russia (CIS) | |
| Andrew Robertson | 26 | 2022 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Andriy Shevchenko | 7 | 2007 | Chelsea | Ukraine | |
| Andy Carroll | 9 | 2012 | Liverpool | England | |
| Andy Cole | 9 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | England | |
| Andy Dibble | 1 | 1988 | Luton Town | Wales | |
| Andy Gray | 9 | 1977 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Andy Gray | 9 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Andy Gray | 9 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Scotland | |
| Andy Impey | 24 | 2000 | Leicester City | England | |
| Andy Linighan | 5 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Andy Sinton | 22 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Andy Thomas | 12 | 1986 | Oxford United | England | |
| Andy Townsend | 14 | 1994 | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | |
| Andy Townsend (c) | 11 | 1996 | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | |
| Àngel Rangel | 22 | 2013 | Swansea City | Spain | |
| Anthony Martial | 11 | 2017 | Manchester United | France | |
| Antonio Valencia | 25 | 2010 | Manchester United | Ecuador | |
| Antonio Valencia | 25 | 2017 | Manchester United | Ecuador | |
| Antony | 21 | 2023 | Manchester United | Brazil | |
| Archie Gemmill | 8 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| Arijanet Muric | 49 | 2019 | Manchester City | Kosovo | |
| Arjen Robben | 16 | 2007 | Chelsea | Netherlands | |
| Arthur Mann | 3 | 1970 | Manchester City | Scotland | |
| Asa Hartford | 10 | 1976 | Manchester City | Scotland | |
| Asa Hartford | 10 | 1985 | Norwich City | Scotland | |
| Ashley Cole | 3 | 2007 | Chelsea | England | |
| Ashley Grimes | 12 | 1988 | Luton Town | Republic of Ireland | |
| Ashley Williams (c) | 6 | 2013 | Swansea City | Wales | |
| Ashley Young | 18 | 2017 | Manchester United | England | |
| Aymeric Laporte | 14 | 2018 | Manchester City | France | |
| Aymeric Laporte | 14 | 2019 | Manchester City | France | |
| Aymeric Laporte | 14 | 2021 | Manchester City | France | |
| Bacary Sagna | 3 | 2016 | Manchester City | France | |
| Barry Bridges | 9 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| Barry Butler | 5 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | England | |
| Barry Butler | 5 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | England | |
| Barry Ferguson | 12 | 2011 | Birmingham City | Scotland | |
| Barry Powell | 12 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Ben Davies | 33 | 2013 | Swansea City | Wales | |
| Ben Foster | 12 | 2009 | Manchester United | England | |
| Ben Foster | 12 | 2010 | Manchester United | England | |
| Ben Foster | 26 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Benjamin Mendy | 22 | 2020 | Manchester City | France | |
| Benjamin Mendy | 22 | 2021 | Manchester City | France | |
| Bernardo Silva | 20 | 2018 | Manchester City | Portugal | |
| Bernardo Silva | 20 | 2019 | Manchester City | Portugal | |
| Bernardo Silva | 20 | 2020 | Manchester City | Portugal | |
| Bernardo Silva | 20 | 2021 | Manchester City | Portugal | |
| Bert Murray | 7 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | England | |
| Bert Murray | 7 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| Bertie Auld | 11 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | Scotland | |
| Bertie Auld | 11 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | Scotland | |
| Bill Punton | 11 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | Scotland | |
| Bill Punton | 11 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | Scotland | |
| Billy Bremner (c) | 4 | 1968 | Leeds United | Scotland | |
| Biram Diouf | 32 | 2010 | Manchester United | Senegal | |
| Bobby Cram | 2 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Bobby Cram | 2 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Bobby Hope | 10 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | Scotland | |
| Bobby McDonald | 6 | 1975 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Bobby Tambling | 11 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | England | |
| Bobby Tambling | 11 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| Bobby Thomson | 8 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Bobby Thomson | 10 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Boudewijn Zenden | 27 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Netherlands | |
| Brad Friedel | 1 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | United States | |
| Brad Jones | 35 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Australia | |
| Branislav Ivanović | 2 | 2015 | Chelsea | Serbia | |
| Brian Laws | 2 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Brian Laws | 2 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Brian Little | 8 | 1975 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Brian Little | 8 | 1977 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Brian Little | 8 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | England | |
| Brian Little | 8 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | England | |
| Brian McClair | 9 | 1992 | Manchester United | Scotland | |
| Brian Stein | 8 | 1988 | Luton Town | England | |
| Bruce Grobbelaar | 1 | 1982 | Liverpool | Zimbabwe | |
| Bruce Grobbelaar | 1 | 1983 | Liverpool | Zimbabwe | |
| Bruce Grobbelaar | 1 | 1984 | Liverpool | Zimbabwe | |
| Bruce Grobbelaar | 1 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Zimbabwe | |
| Bruno Fernandes (c) | 8 | 2023 | Manchester United | Portugal | |
| Cameron Jerome | 10 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Caoimhín Kelleher | 62 | 2022 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Carlos Tevez | 32 | 2009 | Manchester United | Argentina | |
| Casemiro | 18 | 2023 | Manchester United | Brazil | |
| César Azpilicueta | 28 | 2015 | Chelsea | Spain | |
| Cesc Fàbregas | 4 | 2015 | Chelsea | Spain | |
| Charlie Adam | 26 | 2012 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Charlie Aitken | 3 | 1975 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Charlie Nicholas | 10 | 1987 | Arsenal | Scotland | |
| Chico Hamilton | 10 | 1975 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Chris Armstrong | 11 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Chris Nicholl | 5 | 1975 | Aston Villa | Northern Ireland | |
| Chris Nicholl | 5 | 1977 | Aston Villa | Northern Ireland | |
| Chris Nicholl | 5 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | Northern Ireland | |
| Chris Nicholl | 5 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | Northern Ireland | |
| Chris Riggott | 5 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | England | |
| Chris Smalling (c) | 12 | 2017 | Manchester United | England | |
| Chris Turner | 1 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | England | |
| Chris Woods | 1 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Chris Woods | 1 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Chris Woods | 1 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| Christian Ziege | 3 | 2001 | Liverpool | Germany | |
| Claude Makélélé | 4 | 2005 | Chelsea | France | |
| Claude Makélélé | 4 | 2007 | Chelsea | France | |
| Claudio Bravo | 1 | 2018 | Manchester City | Chile | |
| Claudio Bravo | 1 | 2020 | Manchester City | Chile | |
| Clive Clark | 11 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Clive Clark | 11 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Colin Appleton | 3 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | England | |
| Colin Appleton | 3 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | England | |
| Colin Barrett | 2 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Colin Bell | 8 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Colin Brazier | 12 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Colin Green | 3 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | Wales | |
| Colin Green | 3 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | Wales | |
| Colin Irwin | 4 | 1981 | Liverpool | England | |
| Colin Irwin | 12 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Costel Pantilimon | 30 | 2014 | Manchester City | Romania | |
| Craig Bellamy | 39 | 2012 | Liverpool | Wales | |
| Craig Gardner | 8 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Craig Hignett | 15 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | England | |
| Craig Johnston | 10 | 1983 | Liverpool | England | |
| Craig Johnston | 10 | 1984 | Liverpool | Australia | |
| Craig Johnston | 10 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Australia | |
| Cristiano Ronaldo | 7 | 2006 | Manchester United | Portugal | |
| Cristiano Ronaldo | 7 | 2009 | Manchester United | Portugal | |
| Cyril Knowles | 3 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Cyril Knowles | 3 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Daley Blind | 17 | 2017 | Manchester United | Netherlands | |
| Dalian Atkinson | 10 | 1994 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Damien Duff | 11 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | Republic of Ireland | |
| Damien Duff | 11 | 2005 | Chelsea | Republic of Ireland | |
| Dan Petrescu | 2 | 1998 | Chelsea | Romania | |
| Daniel Agger | 5 | 2012 | Liverpool | Denmark | |
| Danilo | 3 | 2018 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Danilo | 3 | 2019 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Danny Campbell | 5 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Danny Campbell | 5 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Danny Mills | 15 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | England | |
| Danny Murphy | 13 | 2003 | Liverpool | England | |
| Danny Welbeck | 19 | 2009 | Manchester United | England | |
| Danny Wilson | 7 | 1988 | Luton Town | Northern Ireland | |
| Danny Wilson | 7 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | Northern Ireland | |
| Darren Anderton | 9 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Darren Bent | 23 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Darren Fletcher | 24 | 2010 | Manchester United | Scotland | |
| Darron Gibson | 28 | 2009 | Manchester United | Republic of Ireland | |
| Darron Gibson | 28 | 2010 | Manchester United | Republic of Ireland | |
| Dave Gibson | 10 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | Scotland | |
| Dave Gibson | 10 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | Scotland | |
| Dave Langan | 2 | 1986 | Oxford United | Republic of Ireland | |
| Dave Wagstaffe | 11 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Dave Watson | 5 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Dave Watson (c) | 6 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| David de Gea | 1 | 2017 | Manchester United | Spain | |
| David de Gea | 1 | 2023 | Manchester United | Spain | |
| David Dunn | 8 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | England | |
| David Fairclough | 12 | 1983 | Liverpool | England | |
| David Ginola | 14 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | France | |
| David Hirst | 9 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | England | |
| David James | 1 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| David Johnson | 12 | 1982 | Liverpool | England | |
| David Murphy | 3 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| David Needham | 6 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| David O'Leary | 5 | 1987 | Arsenal | Republic of Ireland | |
| David O'Leary | 22 | 1993 | Arsenal | Republic of Ireland | |
| David Preece | 10 | 1988 | Luton Town | England | |
| David Rocastle | 7 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| David Seaman | 1 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| David Silva | 21 | 2014 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| David Silva | 21 | 2016 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| David Silva | 21 | 2018 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| David Silva (c) | 21 | 2019 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| David Silva (c) | 21 | 2020 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| Dean Saunders | 9 | 1994 | Aston Villa | Wales | |
| Denis Irwin | 3 | 1992 | Manchester United | Republic of Ireland | |
| Denis Smith | 5 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| Dennis Mortimer | 6 | 1977 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Dennis Mortimer | 6 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | England | |
| Dennis Mortimer | 6 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | England | |
| Dennis Tueart | 11 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Dennis van Wijk | 3 | 1985 | Norwich City | Netherlands | |
| Dennis Wise (c) | 11 | 1998 | Chelsea | England | |
| Derek Dougan | 10 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Northern Ireland | |
| Derek Parkin | 3 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Derek Parkin | 3 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Derrick Lythgoe | 8 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | England | |
| Derrick Lythgoe | 8 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | England | |
| Des Walker | 4 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Des Walker | 4 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Dick Scott | 9 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | England | |
| Dick Scott | 9 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | England | |
| Didier Drogba | 15 | 2005 | Chelsea | Ivory Coast | |
| Didier Drogba | 11 | 2015 | Chelsea | Ivory Coast | |
| Didier Drogba | 11 | 2007 | Chelsea | Ivory Coast | |
| Didier Zokora | 4 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | Ivory Coast | |
| Diego Costa | 19 | 2015 | Chelsea | Spain | |
| Dietmar Hamann | 16 | 2001 | Liverpool | Germany | |
| Dietmar Hamann | 16 | 2003 | Liverpool | Germany | |
| Dimitar Berbatov | 9 | 2010 | Manchester United | Bulgaria | |
| Dimitar Berbatov | 9 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | Bulgaria | |
| Diogo Dalot | 20 | 2023 | Manchester United | Portugal | |
| Diogo Jota | 20 | 2022 | Liverpool | Portugal | |
| Dirk Kuyt | 18 | 2012 | Liverpool | Netherlands | |
| Divock Origi | 27 | 2022 | Liverpool | Belgium | |
| Djimi Traoré | 30 | 2003 | Liverpool | Mali | |
| Don Heath | 7 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| Don Rogers | 11 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| Doni | 32 | 2012 | Liverpool | Brazil | |
| Doriva | 20 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Brazil | |
| Doug Fraser | 4 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | Scotland | |
| Doug Fraser | 4 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | Scotland | |
| Dwight Tiendalli | 21 | 2013 | Swansea City | Netherlands | |
| Dwight Yorke | 10 | 1996 | Aston Villa | Trinidad and Tobago | |
| Earl Barrett | 2 | 1994 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Ed de Goey | 1 | 1998 | Chelsea | Netherlands | |
| Eddie Gray | 11 | 1968 | Leeds United | Scotland | |
| Eddie McCreadie | 9 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | Scotland | |
| Eddie McCreadie | 3 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | Scotland | |
| Eddie Newton | 24 | 1998 | Chelsea | England | |
| Eden Hazard | 10 | 2015 | Chelsea | Belgium | |
| Ederson | 31 | 2018 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Ederson | 31 | 2019 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Ederson | 31 | 2020 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Ederson | 31 | 2021 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Edin Džeko | 10 | 2014 | Manchester City | Bosnia and Herzegovina | |
| Edwin van der Sar | 19 | 2006 | Manchester United | Netherlands | |
| Eiður Guðjohnsen | 22 | 2005 | Chelsea | Iceland | |
| El Hadji Diouf | 9 | 2003 | Liverpool | Senegal | |
| Emile Heskey | 11 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Emile Heskey | 11 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Emile Heskey | 9 | 2000 | Leicester City | England | |
| Emile Heskey | 8 | 2001 | Liverpool | England | |
| Emile Heskey | 8 | 2003 | Liverpool | England | |
| Emlyn Hughes (c) | 5 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Eric Bailly | 3 | 2017 | Manchester United | Ivory Coast | |
| Espen Baardsen | 13 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | Norway | |
| Fabinho | 3 | 2022 | Liverpool | Brazil | |
| Fernandinho | 25 | 2014 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Fernandinho | 25 | 2016 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Fernandinho | 25 | 2018 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Fernandinho | 25 | 2019 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Fernandinho | 25 | 2020 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Fernandinho (c) | 25 | 2021 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Fernando | 6 | 2016 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Ferran Torres | 21 | 2021 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| Filipe Luís | 3 | 2015 | Chelsea | Brazil | |
| Francis Lee | 10 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Franck Queudrue | 3 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | France | |
| Frank Burrows | 5 | 1969 | Swindon Town | Scotland | |
| Frank Carrodus | 11 | 1975 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Frank Carrodus | 11 | 1977 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Frank Carrodus | 11 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | England | |
| Frank Clark | 3 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Frank Clark | 3 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Frank Clark | 3 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Frank Lampard | 8 | 2005 | Chelsea | England | |
| Frank Lampard | 8 | 2007 | Chelsea | England | |
| Frank Leboeuf | 5 | 1998 | Chelsea | France | |
| Frank Munro | 5 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Scotland | |
| Frank Sibley | 6 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Frank Sinclair | 20 | 1998 | Chelsea | Jamaica | |
| Frank Sinclair | 3 | 2000 | Leicester City | Jamaica | |
| Frank Upton | 6 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| Franz Carr | 14 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Franz Carr | 11 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Fred | 17 | 2023 | Manchester United | Brazil | |
| Gabriel Jesus | 33 | 2018 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Gabriel Jesus | 9 | 2020 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Gabriel Jesus | 9 | 2021 | Manchester City | Brazil | |
| Gaël Clichy | 22 | 2014 | Manchester City | France | |
| Gaël Clichy | 22 | 2016 | Manchester City | France | |
| Gaizka Mendieta | 14 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Spain | |
| Gareth Southgate | 4 | 1996 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Gareth Southgate (c) | 6 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | England | |
| Garry Birtles | 9 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Garry Monk | 16 | 2013 | Swansea City | England | |
| Garry Parker | 8 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Garry Parker | 10 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Garry Parker | 10 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Garry Parker | 11 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Gary Briggs | 5 | 1986 | Oxford United | England | |
| Gary Cahill | 24 | 2015 | Chelsea | England | |
| Gary Charles | 2 | 1996 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Gary Crosby | 7 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Gary McAllister | 21 | 2001 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Gary Neville | 2 | 2010 | Manchester United | England | |
| Gary Neville (c) | 2 | 2006 | Manchester United | England | |
| Gary Pallister | 6 | 1992 | Manchester United | England | |
| Gary Pierce | 1 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Gary Sprake | 1 | 1968 | Leeds United | Wales | |
| Ged Keegan | 2 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Geoff Palmer | 2 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Geoff Palmer | 2 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Geoff Sidebottom | 1 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | England | |
| George Berry | 6 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Wales | |
| George Boateng | 7 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Netherlands | |
| George Eastham | 11 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| George Graham | 8 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | Scotland | |
| George Heslop | 7 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Gerhard Tremmel | 25 | 2013 | Swansea City | Germany | |
| Gerry Mannion | 7 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | England | |
| Gerry Mannion | 7 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | England | |
| Gerry Taggart | 4 | 2000 | Leicester City | Northern Ireland | |
| Gianfranco Zola | 25 | 1998 | Chelsea | Italy | |
| Glen Johnson | 2 | 2005 | Chelsea | England | |
| Glen Johnson | 2 | 2012 | Liverpool | England | |
| Glyn Pardoe | 11 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Gordon Banks | 1 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | England | |
| Gordon Banks | 1 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | England | |
| Gordon Banks | 1 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| Gordon Cowans | 10 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | England | |
| Gordon Cowans | 11 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | England | |
| Gordon Lee | 3 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Gordon Lee | 3 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Gordon Smith | 12 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Graeme Le Saux | 14 | 1998 | Chelsea | England | |
| Graeme Souness | 11 | 1981 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Graeme Souness (c) | 11 | 1982 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Graeme Souness (c) | 11 | 1983 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Graeme Souness (c) | 11 | 1984 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Graeme Souness (c) | 11 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Graham Cross | 6 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | England | |
| Graham Cross | 6 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | England | |
| Graham Fenton | 25 | 1994 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Graham Lovett | 10 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Graham Williams | 6 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | Wales | |
| Graham Williams | 6 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | Wales | |
| Harry Burrows | 11 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Harry Maguire | 5 | 2023 | Manchester United | England | |
| Harvey Elliott | 67 | 2022 | Liverpool | England | |
| Henning Berg (c) | 4 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | Norway | |
| Hilário | 40 | 2007 | Chelsea | Portugal | |
| Howard Riley | 7 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | England | |
| Howard Riley | 7 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | England | |
| Ian Bowyer | 12 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Ian Bowyer | 8 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Ian Bowyer | 8 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Ian Bowyer | 12 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Ian King | 5 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | England | |
| Ian King | 5 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | England | |
| Ian Marshall | 20 | 2000 | Leicester City | England | |
| Ian Morgan | 12 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Ian Ross (c) | 4 | 1975 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Ian Rush | 9 | 1981 R | Liverpool | Wales | |
| Ian Rush | 9 | 1982 | Liverpool | Wales | |
| Ian Rush | 9 | 1983 | Liverpool | Wales | |
| Ian Rush | 9 | 1984 | Liverpool | Wales | |
| Ian Rush | 9 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Wales | |
| Ian Rush (c) | 9 | 1995 | Liverpool | Wales | |
| Ian Selley | 4 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Ian Taylor | 7 | 1996 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Ian Walker | 1 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Ian Wright | 8 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Ibrahima Konaté | 5 | 2022 | Liverpool | France | |
| Igor Bišćan | 25 | 2001 | Liverpool | Croatia | |
| Igor Bišćan | 25 | 2003 | Liverpool | Croatia | |
| İlkay Gündoğan | 8 | 2018 | Manchester City | Germany | |
| İlkay Gündoğan | 8 | 2019 | Manchester City | Germany | |
| İlkay Gündoğan | 8 | 2020 | Manchester City | Germany | |
| İlkay Gündoğan | 8 | 2021 | Manchester City | Germany | |
| Itay Shechter | 17 | 2013 | Swansea City | Israel | |
| Jack Charlton | 5 | 1968 | Leeds United | England | |
| Jackie Marsh | 2 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| Jadon Sancho | 25 | 2023 | Manchester United | England | |
| James Milner | 7 | 2014 | Manchester City | England | |
| James Milner | 7 | 2022 | Liverpool | England | |
| Jamie Carragher | 23 | 2001 | Liverpool | England | |
| Jamie Carragher | 23 | 2003 | Liverpool | England | |
| Jamie Carragher | 23 | 2012 | Liverpool | England | |
| Jamie Lawrence | 21 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Jamie Redknapp | 15 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| Javi García | 14 | 2014 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| Jay Spearing | 20 | 2012 | Liverpool | England | |
| Jean Beausejour | 23 | 2011 | Birmingham City | Chile | |
| Jeff Astle | 8 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Jeff Astle | 8 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Jeremy Charles | 9 | 1986 | Oxford United | Wales | |
| Jermaine Jenas | 8 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Jerzy Dudek | 1 | 2003 | Liverpool | Poland | |
| Jesse Lingard | 14 | 2017 | Manchester United | England | |
| Jesús Navas | 15 | 2014 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| Jesús Navas | 15 | 2016 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| Jim Langley | 3 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Jimmy Bloomfield | 8 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Jimmy Bloomfield | 8 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Jimmy Case | 12 | 1981 | Liverpool | England | |
| Jimmy Case | 11 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Jimmy Cumbes | 1 | 1975 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Jimmy Dugdale | 5 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Jimmy Dugdale | 5 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Jimmy Greenhoff | 7 | 1968 | Leeds United | England | |
| Jimmy Greenhoff | 8 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| Jimmy Harris | 9 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Jimmy Harris | 9 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Jimmy Hill | 10 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | Northern Ireland | |
| Jimmy Hill | 10 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | Northern Ireland | |
| Jimmy MacEwan | 7 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Jimmy MacEwan | 7 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Jimmy Neighbour | 11 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Jimmy Pearce | 12 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Jimmy Pearce | 11 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Jiří Jarošík | 27 | 2005 | Chelsea | Czech Republic | |
| João Cancelo | 27 | 2021 | Manchester City | Portugal | |
| Joe Butler | 4 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| Joe Cole | 10 | 2005 | Chelsea | England | |
| Joe Corrigan | 1 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Joe Corrigan | 1 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Joe Hart | 1 | 2014 | Manchester City | England | |
| Joe Hart | 1 | 2016 | Manchester City | England | |
| Joe Kinnear | 2 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | Republic of Ireland | |
| Joe Kinnear | 2 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | Republic of Ireland | |
| Joe Mullett | 6 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | England | |
| Joe Mullett | 6 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | England | |
| Joe Royle | 9 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Joël Matip | 32 | 2022 | Liverpool | Cameroon | |
| John Aldridge | 8 | 1986 | Oxford United | Republic of Ireland | |
| John Arne Riise | 18 | 2003 | Liverpool | Norway | |
| John Barnes | 10 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| John Boyle | 6 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | Scotland | |
| John Boyle | 8 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | Scotland | |
| John Burridge | 1 | 1977 | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Burridge | 1 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Burridge | 1 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Curtis | 2 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | England | |
| John Deehan | 7 | 1977 | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Deehan | 7 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Deehan | 7 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Deehan | 9 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| John Devine | 12 | 1985 | Norwich City | Republic of Ireland | |
| John Gidman | 2 | 1977 | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Gidman | 2 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Gidman | 2 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Harkes | 4 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | United States | |
| John Hollins | 4 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | England | |
| John Kaye | 9 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| John Kaye | 9 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| John Lukic | 1 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| John Mahoney | 12 | 1972 | Stoke City | Wales | |
| John McAlle | 6 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| John McGovern | 4 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| John McGovern (c) | 4 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| John Mortimore | 5 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| John Neal | 2 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Obi Mikel | 12 | 2007 | Chelsea | Nigeria | |
| John O'Hare | 12 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| John O'Hare | 4 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| John O'Shea | 22 | 2006 | Manchester United | Republic of Ireland | |
| John O'Shea | 22 | 2009 | Manchester United | Republic of Ireland | |
| John Pratt | 4 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| John Richards | 9 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| John Richards | 10 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| John Ritchie | 9 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| John Robertson | 11 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| John Robertson | 11 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| John Robertson | 11 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| John Robson | 2 | 1975 | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Robson | 3 | 1977 | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Robson | 3 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Robson | 3 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | England | |
| John Scales | 12 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| John Sheridan | 8 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | Republic of Ireland | |
| John Sjoberg | 2 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | Scotland | |
| John Sjoberg | 2 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | Scotland | |
| John Smith | 9 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| John Stones | 5 | 2018 | Manchester City | England | |
| John Stones | 5 | 2020 | Manchester City | England | |
| John Terry (c) | 26 | 2005 | Chelsea | England | |
| John Terry (c) | 26 | 2007 | Chelsea | England | |
| John Terry (c) | 26 | 2015 | Chelsea | England | |
| John Trewick | 3 | 1986 | Oxford United | England | |
| John Trollope | 3 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| Johnny Giles | 10 | 1968 | Leeds United | Republic of Ireland | |
| Johnny Schofield | 1 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Johnny Schofield | 1 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Joleon Lescott | 6 | 2014 | Manchester City | England | |
| Jordan Henderson (c) | 14 | 2022 | Liverpool | England | |
| Player | No. | Year | Club | Nation | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jonathan de Guzmán | 20 | 2013 | Swansea City | Netherlands | |
| Jonathan Woodgate | 39 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Jonny Evans | 23 | 2009 | Manchester United | Northern Ireland | |
| Jonny Evans | 23 | 2010 | Manchester United | Northern Ireland | |
| Jordan Henderson | 14 | 2012 | Liverpool | England | |
| José Dominguez | 20 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | Portugal | |
| José Enrique | 3 | 2012 | Liverpool | Spain | |
| Joseph-Désiré Job | 16 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Cameroon | |
| Juan Cuadrado | 23 | 2015 | Chelsea | Colombia | |
| Juan Mata | 8 | 2017 | Manchester United | Spain | |
| Juninho | 10 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Brazil | |
| Justin Edinburgh | 12 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Kasey Keller | 13 | 1997 | Leicester City | United States | |
| Kasey Keller | 13 | 1997 R | Leicester City | United States | |
| Keith Fahey | 18 | 2011 | Birmingham City | Republic of Ireland | |
| Keith Gillespie | 18 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | Northern Ireland | |
| Keith Leonard | 9 | 1975 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Keith Sanderson | 8 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Kelechi Iheanacho | 72 | 2016 | Manchester City | Nigeria | |
| Kemy Agustien | 26 | 2013 | Swansea City | Netherlands | |
| Ken Keyworth | 9 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | England | |
| Ken Keyworth | 9 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | England | |
| Ken Leek | 10 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | Wales | |
| Ken Leek | 10 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | Wales | |
| Kenny Burns (c) | 6 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| Kenny Burns (c) | 6 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| Kenny Clements | 12 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Kenny Dalglish | 7 | 1981 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Kenny Dalglish | 7 | 1981 R | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Kenny Dalglish | 7 | 1982 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Kenny Dalglish | 7 | 1983 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Kenny Dalglish | 7 | 1984 | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Kenny Dalglish | 7 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Scotland | |
| Kenny Hibbitt | 8 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Kenny Hibbitt | 7 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Kenny Sansom (c) | 3 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| Kevin Brock | 11 | 1986 | Oxford United | England | |
| Kevin Campbell | 7 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Kevin De Bruyne | 17 | 2018 | Manchester City | Belgium | |
| Kevin De Bruyne | 17 | 2019 | Manchester City | Belgium | |
| Kevin De Bruyne | 17 | 2020 | Manchester City | Belgium | |
| Kevin De Bruyne | 17 | 2021 | Manchester City | Belgium | |
| Kevin Hitchcock | 13 | 1998 | Chelsea | England | |
| Kevin Phillips | 9 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Kevin Poole | 1 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Kevin Poole | 1 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Kevin Richardson (c) | 6 | 1994 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Ki Sung-yueng | 24 | 2013 | Swansea City | South Korea | |
| Kieran Richardson | 23 | 2006 | Manchester United | England | |
| Kingsley Black | 11 | 1988 | Luton Town | Northern Ireland | |
| Kostas Tsimikas | 21 | 2022 | Liverpool | Greece | |
| Kurt Zouma | 5 | 2015 | Chelsea | France | |
| Kyle Walker | 2 | 2018 | Manchester City | England | |
| Kyle Walker | 2 | 2019 | Manchester City | England | |
| Kyle Walker | 2 | 2020 | Manchester City | England | |
| Kyle Walker | 2 | 2021 | Manchester City | England | |
| Larry Lloyd | 5 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Larry Lloyd | 5 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Larry Lloyd | 5 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Lassana Diarra | 19 | 2007 | Chelsea | France | |
| Lawrie Madden | 14 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | England | |
| Ledley King (c) | 26 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Lee Bowyer | 4 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Lee Chapman | 10 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Lee Glover | 14 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| Lee Sharpe | 14 | 1992 | Manchester United | England | |
| Leighton Phillips | 4 | 1977 | Aston Villa | Wales | |
| Leighton Phillips | 4 | 1977 R | Aston Villa | Wales | |
| Leighton Phillips | 4 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | Wales | |
| Lenny Pidgeley | 40 | 2005 | Chelsea | England | |
| Leon Britton | 7 | 2013 | Swansea City | England | |
| Leroy Sané | 19 | 2018 | Manchester City | Germany | |
| Leroy Sané | 19 | 2019 | Manchester City | Germany | |
| Les Allen | 9 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Les Ferdinand | 10 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Les Phillips | 4 | 1986 | Oxford United | England | |
| Liam Ridgewell | 6 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Lisandro Martínez | 6 | 2023 | Manchester United | Argentina | |
| Loïc Rémy | 18 | 2015 | Chelsea | France | |
| Louie Donowa | 11 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| Louis Saha | 9 | 2006 | Manchester United | France | |
| Luis Díaz | 23 | 2022 | Liverpool | Colombia | |
| Luis Suárez | 7 | 2012 | Liverpool | Uruguay | |
| Luke Moore | 19 | 2013 | Swansea City | England | |
| Luke Shaw | 23 | 2023 | Manchester United | England | |
| Luke Young | 32 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Maik Taylor | 1 | 2011 | Birmingham City | Serbia | |
| Mal Donaghy | 6 | 1988 | Luton Town | Northern Ireland | |
| Malcolm Beard | 6 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Malcolm Beard | 6 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Malcolm Shotton (c) | 6 | 1986 | Oxford United | England | |
| Marcel Sabitzer | 15 | 2023 | Manchester United | Austria | |
| Marcos Rojo | 5 | 2017 | Manchester United | Argentina | |
| Marcus Rashford | 19 | 2017 | Manchester United | England | |
| Marcus Rashford | 10 | 2023 | Manchester United | England | |
| Mark Barham | 7 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| Mark Bosnich | 13 | 1994 | Aston Villa | Australia | |
| Mark Bosnich | 1 | 1996 | Aston Villa | Australia | |
| Mark Draper | 8 | 1996 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Mark Hughes | 10 | 1992 | Manchester United | Wales | |
| Mark Hughes | 10 | 1998 | Chelsea | Wales | |
| Mark Hughes | 12 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | Wales | |
| Mark Lawrenson | 3 | 1982 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Mark Lawrenson | 4 | 1983 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Mark Lawrenson | 4 | 1984 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Mark Lawrenson | 4 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Mark Lazarus | 7 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Mark Robins | 12 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Mark Robins | 12 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Mark Schwarzer | 1 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Australia | |
| Mark Stein | 14 | 1988 | Luton Town | England | |
| Mark Walters | 11 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| Markus Babbel | 6 | 2001 | Liverpool | Germany | |
| Marouane Fellaini | 27 | 2017 | Manchester United | Belgium | |
| Martin Chivers | 9 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Martin Chivers | 9 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Martín Demichelis | 26 | 2014 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Martín Demichelis | 26 | 2016 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Martin Hayes | 11 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| Martin Jiránek | 28 | 2011 | Birmingham City | Czech Republic | |
| Martin Kelly | 34 | 2012 | Liverpool | England | |
| Martin O'Neill | 7 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | Northern Ireland | |
| Martin O'Neill | 7 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | Northern Ireland | |
| Martin O'Neill | 7 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | Northern Ireland | |
| Martin Peters | 10 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Martin Peters (c) | 10 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Martin Škrtel | 37 | 2012 | Liverpool | Slovakia | |
| Martin Taylor | 28 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | England | |
| Marvin Hinton | 2 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | England | |
| Marvin Hinton | 2 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| Massimo Maccarone | 9 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | Italy | |
| Mateja Kežman | 9 | 2005 | Chelsea | Serbia and Montenegro | |
| Matt Elliott (c) | 18 | 2000 | Leicester City | Scotland | |
| Matt Jansen | 10 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | England | |
| Max Dougan | 4 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | Scotland | |
| Max Dougan | 4 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | Scotland | |
| Maxi Rodríguez | 11 | 2012 | Liverpool | Argentina | |
| Mel Eves | 11 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Michael Ballack | 13 | 2007 | Chelsea | Germany | |
| Michael Carrick | 16 | 2010 | Manchester United | England | |
| Michael Carrick | 16 | 2017 | Manchester United | England | |
| Michael Duberry | 12 | 1998 | Chelsea | England | |
| Michael Essien | 5 | 2007 | Chelsea | Ghana | |
| Michael Oakes | 13 | 1996 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Michael Owen | 10 | 2003 | Liverpool | England | |
| Michael Owen | 7 | 2010 | Manchester United | England | |
| Michael Owen | 10 | 2001 | Liverpool | England | |
| Michael Ricketts | 17 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | England | |
| Michael Robinson | 12 | 1984 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Michael Robinson | 12 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Michael Thomas | 14 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| Michael Thomas | 16 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| Michel Vorm | 1 | 2013 | Swansea City | Netherlands | |
| Michu | 9 | 2013 | Swansea City | Spain | |
| Mick Channon | 8 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| Mick Harford | 9 | 1988 | Luton Town | England | |
| Mikaël Silvestre | 27 | 2006 | Manchester United | France | |
| Mike Bailey (c) | 4 | 1974 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Mike Bernard | 4 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| Mike Doyle | 4 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Mike Doyle (c) | 4 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Mike England | 5 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | Wales | |
| Mike Hellawell | 7 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Mike Hellawell | 7 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Mike Keen (c) | 4 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Mike Pejic | 3 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| Mike Phelan | 5 | 1992 | Manchester United | England | |
| Mike Stringfellow | 11 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | England | |
| Mike Stringfellow | 11 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | England | |
| Mike Summerbee | 9 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Mike Whitlow | 3 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Mike Whitlow | 3 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Milan Baroš | 5 | 2003 | Liverpool | Czech Republic | |
| Mohamed Salah | 11 | 2022 | Liverpool | Egypt | |
| Muzzy Izzet | 6 | 1997 | Leicester City | Turkey | |
| Muzzy Izzet | 6 | 1997 R | Leicester City | Turkey | |
| Muzzy Izzet | 6 | 2000 | Leicester City | Turkey | |
| Naby Keïta | 8 | 2022 | Liverpool | Guinea | |
| Nani | 17 | 2009 | Manchester United | Portugal | |
| Nathan Aké | 6 | 2015 | Chelsea | Netherlands | |
| Nathan Aké | 6 | 2021 | Manchester City | Netherlands | |
| Nathan Dyer | 12 | 2013 | Swansea City | England | |
| Neil Cox | 17 | 1994 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Neil Lennon | 7 | 1997 | Leicester City | Northern Ireland | |
| Neil Lennon | 7 | 1997 R | Leicester City | Northern Ireland | |
| Neil Lennon | 7 | 2000 | Leicester City | Northern Ireland | |
| Neil Ruddock | 25 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| Neil Webb | 8 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Neil Webb | 12 | 1992 | Manchester United | England | |
| Nemanja Vidić | 15 | 2006 | Manchester United | Serbia and Montenegro | |
| Nemanja Vidić | 15 | 2009 | Manchester United | Serbia | |
| Nemanja Vidić | 15 | 2010 | Manchester United | Serbia | |
| Niall Quinn | 9 | 1987 | Arsenal | Republic of Ireland | |
| Nick Barmby | 20 | 2001 | Liverpool | England | |
| Nicolás Otamendi | 30 | 2016 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Nicolás Otamendi | 30 | 2018 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Nicolás Otamendi | 30 | 2019 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Nicolás Otamendi | 30 | 2020 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Nigel Clough | 9 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Nigel Clough | 9 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Nigel Jemson | 10 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Nigel Pearson (c) | 6 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | England | |
| Nigel Sims | 1 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Nigel Spink | 1 | 1994 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Nigel Winterburn | 3 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Nigel Worthington | 11 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | Northern Ireland | |
| Nikola Žigić | 19 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Nils-Eric Johansson | 14 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | Sweden | |
| Norman Hunter | 6 | 1968 | Leeds United | England | |
| Obafemi Martins | 17 | 2011 | Birmingham City | Nigeria | |
| Oleksandr Zinchenko | 35 | 2018 | Manchester City | Ukraine | |
| Oleksandr Zinchenko | 35 | 2019 | Manchester City | Ukraine | |
| Oleksandr Zinchenko | 11 | 2020 | Manchester City | Ukraine | |
| Oleksandr Zinchenko | 11 | 2021 | Manchester City | Ukraine | |
| Ollie Burton | 4 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | Wales | |
| Ollie Burton | 4 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | Wales | |
| Oscar | 8 | 2015 | Chelsea | Brazil | |
| Pablo Hernández | 11 | 2013 | Swansea City | Spain | |
| Pablo Zabaleta | 5 | 2014 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Pablo Zabaleta | 5 | 2016 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Park Ji-sung | 13 | 2006 | Manchester United | South Korea | |
| Park Ji-sung | 13 | 2009 | Manchester United | South Korea | |
| Park Ji-sung | 13 | 2010 | Manchester United | South Korea | |
| Pascal Chimbonda | 2 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | France | |
| Pat Jennings | 1 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | Northern Ireland | |
| Pat Jennings | 1 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | Northern Ireland | |
| Patrice Evra | 3 | 2006 | Manchester United | France | |
| Patrice Evra | 3 | 2009 | Manchester United | France | |
| Patrice Evra (c) | 3 | 2010 | Manchester United | France | |
| Paul Bradshaw | 1 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Paul Davis | 8 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| Paul Davis | 14 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Paul Haylock | 2 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| Paul Ince | 8 | 1992 | Manchester United | England | |
| Paul Madeley | 9 | 1968 | Leeds United | England | |
| Paul McGrath | 5 | 1994 | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | |
| Paul McGrath | 5 | 1996 | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | |
| Paul Merson | 10 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Paul Parker | 2 | 1992 | Manchester United | England | |
| Paul Pogba | 6 | 2017 | Manchester United | France | |
| Paul Reaney | 2 | 1968 | Leeds United | England | |
| Paul Robinson | 1 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Paul Scholes | 18 | 2009 | Manchester United | England | |
| Paul Scholes | 18 | 2010 | Manchester United | England | |
| Paul Williams | 10 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | England | |
| Paulo Ferreira | 20 | 2005 | Chelsea | Portugal | |
| Pegguy Arphexad | 22 | 2000 | Leicester City | France | |
| Pegguy Arphexad | 19 | 2001 | Liverpool | France | |
| Pegguy Arphexad | 19 | 2003 | Liverpool | France | |
| Pepe Reina | 25 | 2012 | Liverpool | Spain | |
| Perry Groves | 12 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| Peter Barnes | 7 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Peter Bonetti | 1 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | England | |
| Peter Bonetti | 1 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| Peter Collins | 5 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Peter Daniel | 4 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | |
| Peter Dobing | 10 | 1972 | Stoke City | England | |
| Peter Downsborough | 1 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| Peter Lorimer | 8 | 1968 | Leeds United | Scotland | |
| Peter McParland | 9 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | Northern Ireland | |
| Peter McParland | 11 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | Northern Ireland | |
| Peter Mendham | 5 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| Peter Noble | 10 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| Peter Schmeichel | 1 | 1992 | Manchester United | Denmark | |
| Peter Shilton | 1 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Peter Shirtliff | 5 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | England | |
| Peter Springett | 1 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Peter Withe | 9 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Peter Withe | 9 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Petr Čech | 1 | 2005 | Chelsea | Czech Republic | |
| Petr Čech | 1 | 2007 | Chelsea | Czech Republic | |
| Petr Čech | 1 | 2015 | Chelsea | Czech Republic | |
| Phil Babb | 6 | 1995 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Phil Beal | 6 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Phil Beal | 6 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Phil Foden | 47 | 2018 | Manchester City | England | |
| Phil Foden | 47 | 2020 | Manchester City | England | |
| Phil Foden | 47 | 2019 | Manchester City | England | |
| Phil Foden | 47 | 2021 | Manchester City | England | |
| Phil Gilchrist | 15 | 2000 | Leicester City | England | |
| Phil King | 3 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | England | |
| Phil Neal | 2 | 1981 | Liverpool | England | |
| Phil Neal | 2 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Phil Neal | 2 | 1982 | Liverpool | England | |
| Phil Neal | 2 | 1983 | Liverpool | England | |
| Phil Neal | 2 | 1984 | Liverpool | England | |
| Phil Neal | 2 | 1984 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Phil Thompson | 6 | 1982 | Liverpool | England | |
| Phil Thompson (c) | 4 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Pontus Kåmark | 15 | 1997 | Leicester City | Sweden | |
| Pontus Kåmark | 15 | 1997 R | Leicester City | Sweden | |
| Radek Černý | 12 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | Czech Republic | |
| Rafael | 21 | 2010 | Manchester United | Brazil | |
| Raheem Sterling | 7 | 2016 | Manchester City | England | |
| Raheem Sterling | 7 | 2020 | Manchester City | England | |
| Raheem Sterling | 7 | 2021 | Manchester City | England | |
| Raheem Sterling | 7 | 2019 | Manchester City | England | |
| Ralph Brown | 9 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Ralph Coates | 12 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Ramires | 7 | 2015 | Chelsea | Brazil | |
| Ramon Vega | 15 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | Switzerland | |
| Raphaël Varane | 19 | 2023 | Manchester United | France | |
| Ray Clemence | 1 | 1981 | Liverpool | England | |
| Ray Clemence | 1 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Ray Fairfax | 3 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Ray Fairfax | 3 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Ray Graydon | 7 | 1975 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Ray Graydon | 9 | 1977 2R | Aston Villa | England | |
| Ray Houghton | 7 | 1986 | Oxford United | Republic of Ireland | |
| Ray Houghton | 7 | 1994 | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | |
| Ray Kennedy | 5 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Ray Kennedy (c) | 5 | 1981 | Liverpool | England | |
| Ray Parlour | 11 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Ray Potter | 1 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Ray Potter | 1 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Ricardo Carvalho | 6 | 2005 | Chelsea | Portugal | |
| Ricardo Carvalho | 6 | 2007 | Chelsea | Portugal | |
| Richard Eckersley | 42 | 2009 | Manchester United | England | |
| Richie Norman | 8 | 1964 L2 | Leicester City | England | |
| Ricky Hill | 4 | 1988 | Luton Town | England | |
| Rio Ferdinand | 5 | 2006 | Manchester United | England | |
| Rio Ferdinand (c) | 5 | 2009 | Manchester United | England | |
| Riyad Mahrez | 26 | 2019 | Manchester City | Algeria | |
| Riyad Mahrez | 26 | 2020 | Manchester City | Algeria | |
| Riyad Mahrez | 26 | 2021 | Manchester City | Algeria | |
| Rob Johnson | 3 | 1988 | Luton Town | England | |
| Rob Jones | 2 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| Robbie Fowler | 23 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| Robbie Fowler (c) | 9 | 2001 | Liverpool | England | |
| Robbie Keane | 10 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | Republic of Ireland | |
| Robbie Savage | 14 | 2000 | Leicester City | Wales | |
| Roberto Di Matteo | 16 | 1998 | Chelsea | Italy | |
| Rod Belfitt | 12 | 1968 | Leeds United | England | |
| Rod Thomas | 2 | 1969 | Swindon Town | Wales | |
| Rodney Marsh | 10 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Rodri | 16 | 2020 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| Rodri | 16 | 2021 | Manchester City | Spain | |
| Rodrigo Possebon | 34 | 2009 | Manchester United | Brazil | |
| Roger Johnson | 5 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Roger Morgan | 11 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Roger Smart | 8 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| Roland Lamah | 14 | 2013 | Swansea City | Belgium | |
| Roland Nilsson | 2 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | Sweden | |
| Ron Ashman | 3 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | England | |
| Ron Ashman | 3 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | England | |
| Ron Harris | 3 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | England | |
| Ron Harris | 4 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| Ron Hunt | 5 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Ron Wylie | 10 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | Scotland | |
| Ronnie Whelan | 5 | 1982 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Ronnie Whelan | 5 | 1983 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Ronnie Whelan | 5 | 1984 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Ronnie Whelan | 5 | 1984 R | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Roy McCrohan | 2 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | England | |
| Roy McCrohan | 2 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | England | |
| Rúben Dias | 3 | 2021 | Manchester City | Portugal | |
| Ruud van Nistelrooy | 10 | 2006 | Manchester United | Netherlands | |
| Ryan Giggs | 11 | 2006 | Manchester United | Wales | |
| Ryan Giggs | 11 | 2009 | Manchester United | Wales | |
| Ryan Giggs | 11 | 1992 | Manchester United | Wales | |
| Sadio Mané | 10 | 2022 | Liverpool | Senegal | |
| Salomon Kalou | 21 | 2007 | Chelsea | Ivory Coast | |
| Sami Hyypiä | 12 | 2001 | Liverpool | Finland | |
| Sami Hyypiä (c) | 4 | 2003 | Liverpool | Finland | |
| Samir Nasri | 8 | 2014 | Manchester City | France | |
| Sammy Lee | 8 | 1981 | Liverpool | England | |
| Sammy Lee | 8 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Sammy Lee | 8 | 1982 | Liverpool | England | |
| Sammy Lee | 8 | 1983 | Liverpool | England | |
| Sammy Lee | 8 | 1984 | Liverpool | England | |
| Sammy Lee | 8 | 1984 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Sander Westerveld | 1 | 2001 | Liverpool | Netherlands | |
| Sandy Kennon | 1 | 1962 L1 | Norwich City | England | |
| Sandy Kennon | 1 | 1962 L2 | Norwich City | England | |
| Savo Milošević | 9 | 1996 | Aston Villa | Serbia and Montenego | |
| Scott McTominay | 39 | 2023 | Manchester United | Scotland | |
| Scott Taylor | 8 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Sebastian Larsson | 7 | 2011 | Birmingham City | Sweden | |
| Sergio Agüero | 16 | 2014 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Sergio Agüero | 10 | 2018 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Sergio Agüero | 10 | 2019 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Sergio Agüero | 10 | 2020 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Sergio Agüero | 10 | 2021 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Sergio Agüero | 10 | 2016 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Sergio Romero | 20 | 2017 | Manchester United | Argentina | |
| Shaun Teale | 4 | 1994 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Simon Grayson | 2 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Simon Grayson | 2 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Sol Campbell (c) | 23 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Spencer Prior | 17 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Spencer Prior | 17 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Stan Harland (c) | 6 | 1969 | Swindon Town | England | |
| Stan Lynn | 2 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Stan Lynn | 2 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Stan Lynn | 2 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Steed Malbranque | 15 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | France | |
| Stefan Oakes | 29 | 2000 | Leicester City | England | |
| Steffen Freund | 4 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | Germany | |
| Steffen Iversen | 18 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | Norway | |
| Stéphane Henchoz | 2 | 2001 | Liverpool | Switzerland | |
| Stéphane Henchoz | 2 | 2003 | Liverpool | Switzerland | |
| Stephen Carr | 2 | 1999 | Tottenham Hotspur | Republic of Ireland | |
| Stephen Carr (c) | 2 | 2011 | Birmingham City | Republic of Ireland | |
| Steve Bruce | 4 | 1985 | Norwich City | England | |
| Steve Bruce (c) | 4 | 1992 | Manchester United | England | |
| Steve Chettle | 12 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Steve Chettle | 5 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Steve Claridge | 9 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Steve Claridge | 9 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Steve Clarke | 6 | 1998 | Chelsea | Scotland | |
| Steve Elliott | 12 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Steve Foster (c) | 5 | 1988 | Luton Town | England | |
| Steve Guppy | 11 | 2000 | Leicester City | England | |
| Steve Heighway | 9 | 1981 | Liverpool | Republic of Ireland | |
| Steve Hodge | 6 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Steve Hodge | 6 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Steve McManaman | 17 | 1995 | Liverpool | England | |
| Steve Morrow | 15 | 1993 | Arsenal | Northern Ireland | |
| Steve Perryman | 8 | 1971 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Steve Perryman | 8 | 1973 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Steve Staunton | 3 | 1994 | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | |
| Steve Staunton | 12 | 1996 | Aston Villa | Republic of Ireland | |
| Steve Sutton | 1 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Steve Sutton | 1 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Steve Walsh (c) | 5 | 1997 | Leicester City | England | |
| Steve Walsh (c) | 5 | 1997 R | Leicester City | England | |
| Steve Williams | 4 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| Steven Gerrard | 17 | 2001 | Liverpool | England | |
| Steven Gerrard | 17 | 2003 | Liverpool | England | |
| Steven Gerrard (c) | 8 | 2012 | Liverpool | England | |
| Stewart Downing | 19 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | England | |
| Stewart Downing | 19 | 2012 | Liverpool | England | |
| Stig Inge Bjørnebye | 20 | 1995 | Liverpool | Norway | |
| Stig Inge Bjørnebye | 5 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | Norway | |
| Stuart Parnaby | 21 | 2011 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Stuart Pearce (c) | 3 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Stuart Pearce (c) | 3 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Takumi Minamino | 18 | 2022 | Liverpool | Japan | |
| Teemu Tainio | 6 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | Finland | |
| Terry Conroy | 7 | 1972 | Stoke City | Republic of Ireland | |
| Terry Cooper | 3 | 1968 | Leeds United | England | |
| Terry Heath | 8 | 1964 L1 | Leicester City | England | |
| Terry Hennessey | 4 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | Wales | |
| Terry Hennessey | 4 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | Wales | |
| Terry McDermott | 10 | 1981 | Liverpool | England | |
| Terry McDermott | 10 | 1981 R | Liverpool | England | |
| Terry McDermott | 10 | 1982 | Liverpool | England | |
| Terry Venables (c) | 10 | 1965 L1 | Chelsea | England | |
| Terry Venables (c) | 10 | 1965 L2 | Chelsea | England | |
| Terry Wilson | 5 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| Terry Wilson | 12 | 1990 | Nottingham Forest | Scotland | |
| Theodoros Zagorakis | 37 | 2000 | Leicester City | Greece | |
| Thibaut Courtois | 13 | 2015 | Chelsea | Belgium | |
| Tiago | 30 | 2005 | Chelsea | Portugal | |
| Tim Breacker | 2 | 1988 | Luton Town | England | |
| Tim Flowers | 1 | 2000 | Leicester City | England | |
| Tim Howard | 1 | 2006 | Manchester United | United States | |
| Tom Heaton | 22 | 2023 | Manchester United | England | |
| Tom Huddlestone | 22 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | England | |
| Tomasz Kuszczak | 29 | 2009 | Manchester United | Poland | |
| Tomasz Kuszczak | 29 | 2010 | Manchester United | Poland | |
| Tommy Booth | 5 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Tommy Booth | 8 | 1976 | Manchester City | England | |
| Tommy Gaynor | 7 | 1989 | Nottingham Forest | Republic of Ireland | |
| Tommy Johnson | 14 | 1996 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Tony Adams | 6 | 1987 | Arsenal | England | |
| Tony Adams (c) | 6 | 1993 | Arsenal | England | |
| Tony Book (c) | 2 | 1970 | Manchester City | England | |
| Tony Brown | 7 | 1966 L1 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Tony Brown | 7 | 1966 L2 | West Bromwich Albion | England | |
| Tony Cottee | 27 | 2000 | Leicester City | England | |
| Tony Daley | 11 | 1994 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Tony Hazell | 2 | 1967 | Queens Park Rangers | England | |
| Tony Woodcock | 10 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Tony Woodcock | 10 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Tony Woodcock | 10 | 1979 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Tore André Flo | 19 | 1998 | Chelsea | Norway | |
| Trent Alexander-Arnold | 66 | 2022 | Liverpool | England | |
| Trevor Francis | 12 | 1991 | Sheffield Wednesday | England | |
| Trevor Hebberd | 10 | 1986 | Oxford United | England | |
| Trevor Smith (c) | 5 | 1963 L1 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Trevor Smith (c) | 5 | 1963 L2 | Birmingham City | England | |
| Tyrell Malacia | 12 | 2023 | Manchester United | Netherlands | |
| Ugo Ehiogu | 6 | 1996 | Aston Villa | England | |
| Ugo Ehiogu | 4 | 2004 | Middlesbrough | England | |
| Vic Crowe | 4 | 1961 L1 | Aston Villa | Wales | |
| Vic Crowe | 4 | 1961 L2 | Aston Villa | Wales | |
| Victor Lindelöf | 2 | 2023 | Manchester United | Sweden | |
| Vincent Kompany | 4 | 2019 | Manchester City | Belgium | |
| Vincent Kompany (c) | 4 | 2014 | Manchester City | Belgium | |
| Vincent Kompany (c) | 4 | 2016 | Manchester City | Belgium | |
| Vincent Kompany (c) | 4 | 2018 | Manchester City | Belgium | |
| Virgil van Dijk | 4 | 2022 | Liverpool | Netherlands | |
| Viv Anderson | 2 | 1978 | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Viv Anderson | 2 | 1978 R | Nottingham Forest | England | |
| Viv Anderson | 2 | 1987 | Arsenal | Wales | |
| Vladimír Šmicer | 7 | 2001 | Liverpool | Czech Republic | |
| Vladimír Šmicer | 7 | 2003 | Liverpool | Czech Republic | |
| Wayne Bridge | 18 | 2007 | Chelsea | England | |
| Wayne Rooney | 8 | 2006 | Manchester United | England | |
| Wayne Rooney | 10 | 2010 | Manchester United | England | |
| Wayne Rooney | 10 | 2017 | Manchester United | England | |
| Wayne Routledge | 15 | 2013 | Swansea City | England | |
| Wes Brown | 6 | 2006 | Manchester United | England | |
| Wes Brown | 6 | 2010 | Manchester United | England | |
| Wilfried Bony | 14 | 2016 | Manchester City | Ivory Coast | |
| William Gallas | 13 | 2005 | Chelsea | France | |
| Willian | 22 | 2015 | Chelsea | Brazil | |
| Willie Carr | 8 | 1980 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Scotland | |
| Willie Donachie | 3 | 1976 | Manchester City | Scotland | |
| Willie Penman | 12 | 1969 | Swindon Town | Scotland | |
| Willy Caballero | 13 | 2016 | Manchester City | Argentina | |
| Wout Weghorst | 27 | 2023 | Manchester United | Netherlands | |
| Yaya Touré | 42 | 2014 | Manchester City | Ivory Coast | |
| Yaya Touré | 42 | 2016 | Manchester City | Ivory Coast | |
| Yordi | 17 | 2002 | Blackburn Rovers | Spain | |
| Younès Kaboul | 5 | 2008 | Tottenham Hotspur | France | |
| Zack Steffen | 13 | 2021 | Manchester City | United States | |
| Zlatan Ibrahimović | 9 | 2017 | Manchester United | Sweden | |