The eight goalkeepers who wore the Everton Number One Shirt in the Premier League are:
- Neville Southall (1993-97)
- Thomas Myhre (1998-2000)
- Paul Gerrard (2000-02)
- Richard Wright (2002-07)
- Carlo Nash (2008-10)
- Ján Mucha (2010-13)
- Joel Robles (2013-17)
- Jordan Pickford (2017-26)
