Home > England Football > FA Cup > FA Cup Winners
FA Cup Winning Players 1872-1939
Explore our FA Cup Winning Players from 1872 to 1939.
The early years were dominated by Gentleman Amateur Clubs from Southern England.
This all changed when Blackburn Olympic, a Northern Professional working class Club, won the 1883 FA Cup Final.
No Amateur Club would ever win the FA Cup again.
Tottenham Hotspur from the Southern League won the 1901 FA Cup Final.
The first Wembley Stadium Final was in 1923.
FA Cup Winning Players 1872 to 1939 Chronological
| Year | Player | Club | Nation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1872 | Reginald Courtenay Welch | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | Edgar Lubbock | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | Albert Thompson | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | C. W. Alcock | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | Edward Bowen | Wanderers | Ireland |
| 1872 | Alexander Bonsor | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | Morton Betts | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | William Crake | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | Thomas Hooman | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | Walpole Vidal | Wanderers | England |
| 1872 | Charles Wollaston | Wanderers | England |
| 1873 | Reginald de Courtenay Welch | Wanderers | England |
| 1873 | Leonard Howell | Wanderers | England |
| 1873 | Edward Bowen | Wanderers | Ireland |
| 1873 | Charles Wollaston | Wanderers | England |
| 1873 | Robert Kingsford | Wanderers | England |
| 1873 | Alexander Bonsor | Wanderers | England |
| 1873 | Capt. William Kenyon-Slaney | Wanderers | England |
| 1873 | Charles Thompson | Wanderers | England |
| 1873 | Julian Sturgis | Wanderers | United States |
| 1873 | Arthur Kinnaird | Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1873 | Rev. Henry Holmes Stewart | Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1874 | Charles Nepean | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | Charles Mackarness | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | Francis Birley | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | Frederick Green | Oxford University | Wales |
| 1874 | Robert Benson | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | Frederick Maddison | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | William Rawson | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | Cuthbert Ottaway | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | Rev. Arthur Johnson | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | Walpole Vidal | Oxford University | England |
| 1874 | Frederick Patton | Oxford University | England |
| 1875 | Capt William Merriman | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Lieut George Hamilton Sim | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Lieut Gerald Onslow | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Lieut Richard Ruck | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Lieut Pelham von Donop | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Lieut Charles Wood | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Lieut Herbert Rawson | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Lieut William FH Stafford | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Capt Henry Renny-Tailyour | Royal Engineers | Scotland |
| 1875 | Lieut Alexander Mein | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 | Lieut Cecil Wingfield-Stratford | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Capt William Merriman | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Lieut George Hamilton Sim | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Lieut Gerald Onslow | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Lieut Richard Ruck | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Lieut Pelham von Donop | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Lieut Charles Wood | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Lieut Herbert Rawson | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Lieut William FH Stafford | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Capt Henry Renny-Tailyour | Royal Engineers | Scotland |
| 1875 R | Lieut Cecil Wingfield-Stratford | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1875 R | Lieut Alexander Mein | Royal Engineers | England |
| 1876 | W. D. O. Greig | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | Alfred Stratford | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | William Lindsay | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | Frederick Maddison | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | Francis Birley | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | Charles Wollaston | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | Francis Heron | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | Hubert Heron | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | John Hawley Edwards | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | Jarvis Kenrick | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 | Thomas Hughes | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | W. D. O. Greig | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | Alfred Stratford | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | William Lindsay | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | Frederick Maddison | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | Francis Birley | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | Charles Wollaston | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | Francis Heron | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | Hubert Heron | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | John Hawley Edwards | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | Jarvis Kenrick | Wanderers | England |
| 1876 R | Thomas Hughes | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Arthur Kinnaird | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Alfred Stratford | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | William Lindsay | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Francis Birley | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Frederick Green | Wanderers | Wales |
| 1877 | Charles Wollaston | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Thomas Hughes | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Hubert Heron | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Henry Wace | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Charles Denton | Wanderers | England |
| 1877 | Jarvis Kenrick | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | James Kirkpatrick | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | Alfred Stratford | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | William Lindsay | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | Hon. Arthur Kinnaird (Captain) | Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1878 | Frederick Green | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | Charles Wollaston | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | Hubert Heron | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | John Wylie | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | Henry Wace | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | Charles Denton | Wanderers | England |
| 1878 | Jarvis Kenrick | Wanderers | England |
| 1879 | John Purvis Hawtrey | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | Edward Christian | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | Lindsay Bury | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | Hon Arthur Kinnaird (C) | Old Etonians | Scotland |
| 1879 | Edgar Lubbock | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | Charles Clerke | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | Norman Pares | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | Harry Goodhart | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | Herbert Whitfeld | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | John Chevallier | Old Etonians | England |
| 1879 | Mark Beaufoy | Old Etonians | England |
| 1880 | Reginald Birkett | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Robert Ogilvie | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Edgar Field | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Vincent Weston | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Norman Bailey | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Arthur J. Stanley | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Harold Brougham | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Francis Sparks | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Felix Barry | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Edward Ram | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1880 | Clopton Lloyd-Jones | Clapham Rovers | England |
| 1881 | Leonard Gillett | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | Walter Norris | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | Sir Elliott Colvin | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | James F. M. Prinsep | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | Sir Joseph Vintcent Jnr. | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | Walter Hansell | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | Lewis Richards | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | William Page | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | Edward Wynyard | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1881 | Edward Hagarty Parry | Old Carthusians | Canada |
| 1881 | Alexander Tod | Old Carthusians | England |
| 1882 | John Rawlinson | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | Thomas French | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | Percy de Paravicini | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | Hon Arthur Kinnaird | Old Etonians | Scotland |
| 1882 | Charles Foley | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | Philip Novelli | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | Arthur Dunn | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | Reginald Macaulay | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | Harry Goodhart | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | John Barrington Chevallier | Old Etonians | England |
| 1882 | William Anderson | Old Etonians | England |
| 1883 | Thomas Hacking | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | James Ward | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | Albert Warburton | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | Thomas Gibson | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | William Astley | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | Jack Hunter | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | Thomas Dewhurst | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | Alfred Matthews | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | George Wilson | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | James Costley | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1883 | John Yates | Blackburn Olympic | England |
| 1884 | Herby Arthur | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1884 | Fergus Suter | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1884 | Joe Beverley | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1884 | Hugh McIntyre (c) | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1884 | Jimmy Forrest | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1884 | Joe Lofthouse | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1884 | Jimmy Douglas | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1884 | John Hargreaves | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1884 | James Brown | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1884 | Joe Sowerbutts | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1884 | John Inglis | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1885 | Herby Arthur | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1885 | Richard Turner | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1885 | Fergus Suter | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1885 | George Haworth | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1885 | Hugh McIntyre | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1885 | Jimmy Forrest | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1885 | Joe Sowerbutts | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1885 | Joe Lofthouse | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1885 | Jimmy Douglas | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1885 | James Brown | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1885 | Howard Fecitt | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 | Herby Arthur | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 | Richard Turner | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 | Fergus Suter | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1886 | Joseph Heyes | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 | Jimmy Forrest | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 | Hugh McIntyre | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1886 | Jimmy Douglas | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1886 | Thomas Strahan | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 | Joe Sowerbutts | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 | Howard Fecitt | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 | James Brown (Captain) | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 R | Herby Arthur | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 R | Richard Turner | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 R | Fergus Suter | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1886 R | Nat Walton | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 R | Jimmy Forrest | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 R | Hugh McIntyre | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1886 R | Jimmy Douglas | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1886 R | Thomas Strahan | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 R | Joe Sowerbutts | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 R | Howard Fecitt | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1886 R | James Brown (Captain) | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1887 | Jimmy Warner | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | Frank Coulton | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | Joseph Simmonds | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | John Burton | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | Harry Yates | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | Frankie Dawson | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | Richmond Davis | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | Albert Brown | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | Archie Hunter (Captain) | Aston Villa | Scotland |
| 1887 | Howard Vaughton | Aston Villa | England |
| 1887 | Dennis Hodgetts | Aston Villa | England |
| 1888 | Bob Roberts | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | Albert Aldridge | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | Harry Green | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | Ezra Horton | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | Charlie Perry | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | George Timmins | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | George Woodhall | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | Billy Bassett | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | Jem Bayliss (Captain) | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | Joe Wilson | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1888 | Tom Pearson | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1889 | Robert Mills-Roberts | Preston North End | Wales |
| 1889 | Bob Howarth | Preston North End | England |
| 1889 | Bob Holmes | Preston North End | England |
| 1889 | George Drummond | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1889 | David Russell | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1889 | Johnny Graham | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1889 | Jack Gordon | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1889 | Jimmy Ross | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1889 | John Goodall | Preston North End | England |
| 1889 | Fred Dewhurst (c) | Preston North End | England |
| 1889 | Sammy Thomson | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1890 | Johnny Horne | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1890 | James Southworth | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1890 | John Forbes | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1890 | John Barton | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1890 | Geordie Dewar | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1890 | Jimmy Forrest | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1890 | Joe Lofthouse | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1890 | Harry Campbell | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1890 | Jack Southworth | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1890 | Nat Walton | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1890 | William Townley | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1891 | Rowland Pennington | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1891 | Tom Brandon | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1891 | John Forbes | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1891 | John Barton | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1891 | Geordie Dewar | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1891 | Jimmy Forrest | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1891 | Joe Lofthouse | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1891 | Nat Walton | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1891 | Jack Southworth | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1891 | Coombe Hall | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1891 | William Townley | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1892 | Joe Reader | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1892 | Mark Nicholson | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1892 | Thomas McCulloch | West Bromwich Albion | Scotland |
| 1892 | Jack Reynolds | West Bromwich Albion | Ireland |
| 1892 | Charlie Perry | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1892 | Willie Groves | West Bromwich Albion | Scotland |
| 1892 | Billy Bassett | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1892 | Roddy McLeod | West Bromwich Albion | Scotland |
| 1892 | Sammy Nicholls | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1892 | Tom Pearson | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1892 | Alfred Geddes | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1893 | Billy Rose | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | Dickie Baugh | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | George Swift | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | Billy Malpass | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | Harry Allen (c) | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | George Kinsey | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | Robert Topham | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | David Wykes | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | Joe Butcher | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | Harry Wood | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1893 | Arthur Griffin | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1894 | George Toone | Notts County | England |
| 1894 | Fay Harper | Notts County | England |
| 1894 | Jack Hendry | Notts County | Scotland |
| 1894 | Charlie Bramley | Notts County | England |
| 1894 | David Calderhead | Notts County | Scotland |
| 1894 | Alf Shelton | Notts County | England |
| 1894 | Arthur Watson | Notts County | England |
| 1894 | Sam Donnelly | Notts County | Scotland |
| 1894 | James Logan | Notts County | Scotland |
| 1894 | Dan Bruce | Notts County | Scotland |
| 1894 | Harry Daft | Notts County | England |
| 1895 | Tom Wilkes | Aston Villa | England |
| 1895 | Howard Spencer | Aston Villa | England |
| 1895 | Jimmy Welford | Aston Villa | England |
| 1895 | Jack Reynolds | Aston Villa | Ireland |
| 1895 | James Cowan | Aston Villa | Scotland |
| 1895 | George Russell | Aston Villa | Scotland |
| 1895 | Charlie Athersmith | Aston Villa | England |
| 1895 | Bob Chatt | Aston Villa | England |
| 1895 | John Devey | Aston Villa | England |
| 1895 | Dennis Hodgetts | Aston Villa | England |
| 1895 | Stephen Smith | Aston Villa | England |
| 1896 | Jimmy Massey | The Wednesday | England |
| 1896 | Jack Earp (c) | The Wednesday | England |
| 1896 | Ambrose Langley | The Wednesday | England |
| 1896 | Harry Brandon | The Wednesday | England |
| 1896 | Tommy Crawshaw | The Wednesday | England |
| 1896 | Bob Petrie | The Wednesday | Scotland |
| 1896 | Archie Brash | The Wednesday | Scotland |
| 1896 | Alec Brady | The Wednesday | Scotland |
| 1896 | Laurie Bell | The Wednesday | Scotland |
| 1896 | Harry Davis | The Wednesday | England |
| 1896 | Fred Spiksley | The Wednesday | England |
| 1897 | Jimmy Whitehouse | Aston Villa | England |
| 1897 | Howard Spencer | Aston Villa | England |
| 1897 | Jack Reynolds | Aston Villa | Ireland |
| 1897 | Albert Evans (c) | Aston Villa | England |
| 1897 | James Cowan | Aston Villa | Scotland |
| 1897 | Jimmy Crabtree | Aston Villa | England |
| 1897 | Charlie Athersmith | Aston Villa | England |
| 1897 | Jack Devey | Aston Villa | England |
| 1897 | John Campbell | Aston Villa | Scotland |
| 1897 | Fred Wheldon | Aston Villa | England |
| 1897 | John Cowan | Aston Villa | Scotland |
| 1898 | Dan Allsopp | Nottingham Forest | England |
| 1898 | Archie Ritchie | Nottingham Forest | Scotland |
| 1898 | Adam Scott | Nottingham Forest | Scotland |
| 1898 | Frank Forman (c) | Nottingham Forest | England |
| 1898 | John McPherson | Nottingham Forest | Scotland |
| 1898 | Willie Wragg | Nottingham Forest | England |
| 1898 | Tom McInnes | Nottingham Forest | Scotland |
| 1898 | Charlie Richards | Nottingham Forest | England |
| 1898 | Len Benbow | Nottingham Forest | England |
| 1898 | Arthur Capes | Nottingham Forest | England |
| 1898 | Alf Spouncer | Nottingham Forest | England |
| 1899 | Willie Foulke | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | Harry Thickett | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | Peter Boyle | Sheffield United | Ireland |
| 1899 | Harry Johnson | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | Tom Morren | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | Ernest Needham | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | Walter Bennett | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | Billy Beer | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | George Hedley | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | Jack Almond | Sheffield United | England |
| 1899 | Fred Priest | Sheffield United | England |
| 1900 | Fred Thompson | Bury | England |
| 1900 | Jack Darroch | Bury | Scotland |
| 1900 | Tommy Davidson | Bury | Scotland |
| 1900 | Jack Pray | Bury | Scotland |
| 1900 | Joe Leeming | Bury | England |
| 1900 | George Ross | Bury | England |
| 1900 | Billy Richards | Bury | England |
| 1900 | Willie Wood | Bury | England |
| 1900 | Jasper McLuckie | Bury | Scotland |
| 1900 | Charlie Sagar | Bury | England |
| 1900 | Jack Plant | Bury | England |
| 1901 | George Clawley | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1901 | Harry Erentz | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1901 | Sandy Tait | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1901 | Tom Morris | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1901 | Ted Hughes | Tottenham Hotspur | Wales |
| 1901 | Jack L Jones (c) | Tottenham Hotspur | Wales |
| 1901 | Tom Smith | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1901 | John Cameron | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1901 | Sandy Brown | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1901 | David Copeland | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1901 | Jack Kirwan | Tottenham Hotspur | Ireland |
| 1901 R | George Clawley | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1901 R | Harry Erentz | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1901 R | Sandy Tait | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1901 R | Tom Morris | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1901 R | Ted Hughes | Tottenham Hotspur | Wales |
| 1901 R | Jack L Jones (c) | Tottenham Hotspur | Wales |
| 1901 R | Tom Smith | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1901 R | John Cameron | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1901 R | Sandy Brown | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1901 R | David Copeland | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1901 R | Jack Kirwan | Tottenham Hotspur | Ireland |
| 1902 | Willie Foulke | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | Harry Thickett | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | Peter Boyle | Sheffield United | Ireland |
| 1902 | Ernest Needham (c) | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | Bernie Wilkinson | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | Harry Johnson | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | Walter Bennett | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | Alf Common | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | George Hedley | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | Fred Priest | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 | Bert Lipsham | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Willie Foulke | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Harry Thickett | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Peter Boyle | Sheffield United | Ireland |
| 1902 R | Ernest Needham (c) | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Bernie Wilkinson | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Harry Johnson | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Walter Bennett | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Alf Common | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | George Hedley | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Fred Priest | Sheffield United | England |
| 1902 R | Bert Lipsham | Sheffield United | England |
| Year | Player | Club | Nation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1903 | Hugh Monteith | Bury | Scotland |
| 1903 | Jimmy Lindsay | Bury | England |
| 1903 | James McEwen | Bury | England |
| 1903 | John Johnston | Bury | Scotland |
| 1903 | Frank Thorpe | Bury | England |
| 1903 | George Ross (c) | Bury | England |
| 1903 | Billy Richards | Bury | England |
| 1903 | Willie Wood | Bury | England |
| 1903 | Charlie Sagar | Bury | England |
| 1903 | Joe Leeming | Bury | England |
| 1903 | Jack Plant | Bury | England |
| 1904 | Jack Hillman | Manchester City | England |
| 1904 | Johnny McMahon | Manchester City | England |
| 1904 | Herbert Burgess | Manchester City | England |
| 1904 | Sammy Frost | Manchester City | England |
| 1904 | Tommy Hynds | Manchester City | Scotland |
| 1904 | Sam Ashworth | Manchester City | England |
| 1904 | Billy Meredith | Manchester City | Wales |
| 1904 | George Livingstone | Manchester City | Scotland |
| 1904 | Billie Gillespie | Manchester City | Scotland |
| 1904 | Sandy Turnbull | Manchester City | Scotland |
| 1904 | Frank Booth | Manchester City | England |
| 1905 | Billy George | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Howard Spencer (c) | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Alf Miles | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Joe Pearson | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Alex Leake | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Jack Windmill | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Billy Brawn | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Billy Garraty | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Harry Hampton | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Joe Bache | Aston Villa | England |
| 1905 | Bert Hall | Aston Villa | England |
| 1906 | Billy Scott | Everton | Ireland |
| 1906 | Walter Balmer | Everton | England |
| 1906 | Jack Crelley | Everton | England |
| 1906 | Harry Makepeace | Everton | England |
| 1906 | Jack Taylor (c) | Everton | Scotland |
| 1906 | Walter Abbott | Everton | England |
| 1906 | Jack Sharp | Everton | England |
| 1906 | Hugh Bolton | Everton | Scotland |
| 1906 | Alex "Sandy" Young | Everton | Scotland |
| 1906 | Jimmy Settle | Everton | England |
| 1906 | Harold Hardman | Everton | England |
| 1907 | Jack Lyall | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | Billy Layton | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | Harry Burton | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | Tom Brittleton | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | Tommy Crawshaw | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | Bill Bartlett | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | Harry Chapman | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | Frank Bradshaw | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | Andrew Wilson | The Wednesday | Scotland |
| 1907 | James Stewart | The Wednesday | England |
| 1907 | George Simpson | The Wednesday | England |
| 1908 | Tommy Lunn | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | Jackery Jones | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | Ted Collins | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | Kenneth Hunt | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | Billy Wooldridge (c) | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | Alf Bishop | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | Billy Harrison | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | Jack Shelton | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | George Hedley | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1908 | Wally Radford | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1908 | Jack Pedley | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England |
| 1909 | Harry Clay | Manchester United | England |
| 1909 | Archie Annan | Manchester United | Scotland |
| 1909 | Joe Cottle | Manchester United | England |
| 1909 | Pat Hanlin | Manchester United | Scotland |
| 1909 | Billy Wedlock | Manchester United | England |
| 1909 | Arthur Spear | Manchester United | England |
| 1909 | Fred Staniforth | Manchester United | England |
| 1909 | Bob Hardy | Manchester United | England |
| 1909 | Sam Gilligan | Manchester United | Scotland |
| 1909 | Andy Burton | Manchester United | Scotland |
| 1909 | Frank Hilton | Manchester United | England |
| 1910 | Jimmy Lawrence | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 | Bill McCracken | Newcastle United | Ireland |
| 1910 | Tony Whitson | Newcastle United | South Africa |
| 1910 | Colin Veitch (c) | Newcastle United | England |
| 1910 | Wilf Low | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 | Peter McWilliam | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 | Jock Rutherford | Newcastle United | England |
| 1910 | James Howie | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 | Albert Shepherd | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 | Sandy Higgins | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 | George Wilson | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 R | Jimmy Lawrence | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 R | Bill McCracken | Newcastle United | Ireland |
| 1910 R | Jack Carr | Newcastle United | England |
| 1910 R | Colin Veitch (c) | Newcastle United | England |
| 1910 R | Wilf Low | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 R | Peter McWilliam | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 R | Jock Rutherford | Newcastle United | England |
| 1910 R | James Howie | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 R | Albert Shepherd | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 R | Sandy Higgins | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1910 R | George Wilson | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1911 | Mark Mellors | Bradford City | England |
| 1911 | Robert Campbell | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 | David Taylor | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 | George Robinson | Bradford City | England |
| 1911 | Willie Gildea | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 | Jimmy McDonald | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 | Peter Logan | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 | Jimmy Speirs (c) | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 | Frank O'Rourke | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 | Archie Devine | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 | Frank Thompson | Bradford City | Ireland |
| 1911 R | Mark Mellors | Bradford City | England |
| 1911 R | Robert Campbell | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 R | David Taylor | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 R | George Robinson | Bradford City | England |
| 1911 R | Bob Torrance | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 R | Jimmy McDonald | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 R | Peter Logan | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 R | Jimmy Speirs (c) | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 R | Frank O'Rourke | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 R | Archie Devine | Bradford City | Scotland |
| 1911 R | Frank Thompson | Bradford City | Ireland |
| 1912 | Jack Cooper | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 | Dickie Downs | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 | Archie Taylor (c) | Barnsley | Scotland |
| 1912 | Bob Glendenning | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 | Philip Bratley | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 | George Utley | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 | Wilfred Bartrop | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 | Harry Tufnell | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 | George Lillycrop | Barnsley | Scotland |
| 1912 | George Travers | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 | Jimmy Moore | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | Jack Cooper | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | Dickie Downs | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | Archie Taylor (c) | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | Bob Glendenning | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | Philip Bratley | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | George Utley | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | Wilfred Bartrop | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | Harry Tufnell | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | George Lillycrop | Barnsley | Scotland |
| 1912 R | George Travers | Barnsley | England |
| 1912 R | Jimmy Moore | Barnsley | England |
| 1913 | Sam Hardy | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Tom Lyons | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Tommy Weston | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Tommy Barber | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Jimmy Harrop | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Jimmy Leach | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Charlie Wallace | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Clem Stephenson | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Harry Hampton | Aston Villa | Scotland |
| 1913 | Harold Halse | Aston Villa | England |
| 1913 | Joseph Bache | Aston Villa | England |
| 1914 | Ronnie Sewell | Burnley | England |
| 1914 | Tom Bamford | Burnley | England |
| 1914 | David Taylor | Burnley | Scotland |
| 1914 | George Halley | Burnley | Scotland |
| 1914 | Tommy Boyle (c) | Burnley | England |
| 1914 | Billy Watson | Burnley | England |
| 1914 | Billy Nesbitt | Burnley | England |
| 1914 | Dick Lindley | Burnley | England |
| 1914 | Bert Freeman | Burnley | Scotland |
| 1914 | Teddy Hodgson | Burnley | England |
| 1914 | Eddie Mosscrop | Burnley | England |
| 1915 | Harold Gough | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Billy Cook | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Jack English | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Albert Sturgess | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Bill Brelsford | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | George Utley (c) | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Jimmy Simmons | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Stanley Fazackerley | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Joseph Kitchen | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Wally Masterman | Sheffield United | England |
| 1915 | Bob Evans | Sheffield United | Wales |
| 1920 | Sam Hardy | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Tommy Smart | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Tommy Weston | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Andy Ducat (c) | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Frank Barson | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Frank Moss | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Charlie Wallace | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Billy Kirton | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Billy Walker | Aston Villa | Scotland |
| 1920 | Clem Stephenson | Aston Villa | England |
| 1920 | Arthur Dorrell | Aston Villa | England |
| 1921 | Alex Hunter | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1921 | Tommy Clay | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1921 | Bob McDonald | Tottenham Hotspur | Scotland |
| 1921 | Bert Smith | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1921 | Charlie Walters | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1921 | Arthur Grimsdell (c) | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1921 | Jimmy Banks | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1921 | Jimmy Seed | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1921 | Jimmy Cantrell | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1921 | Bert Bliss | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1921 | Jimmy Dimmock | Tottenham Hotspur | England |
| 1922 | Sandy Mutch | Huddersfield Town | Scotland |
| 1922 | James Wood | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | Sam Wadsworth | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | Charlie Slade | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | Tom Wilson (c) | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | Billy Watson | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | George Richardson | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | Frank Mann | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | Ernie Islip | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | Clem Stephenson | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1922 | Billy Smith | Huddersfield Town | England |
| 1923 | Dick Pym | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1923 | Bob Haworth | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1923 | Alex Finney | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1923 | Harry Nuttall | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1923 | Jimmy Seddon | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1923 | Billy Jennings | Bolton Wanderers | Wales |
| 1923 | Billy Butler | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1923 | David Jack | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1923 | Jack Smith | Bolton Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1923 | Joe Smith (c) | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1923 | Ted Vizard | Bolton Wanderers | Wales |
| 1924 | Bill Bradley | Newcastle United | England |
| 1924 | Billy Hampson | Newcastle United | England |
| 1924 | Frank Hudspeth (c) | Newcastle United | England |
| 1924 | Peter Mooney | Newcastle United | England |
| 1924 | Charlie Spencer | Newcastle United | England |
| 1924 | Willie Gibson | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1924 | James Low | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1924 | Billy Cowan | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1924 | Neil Harris | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1924 | Tommy McDonald | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1924 | Stan Seymour | Newcastle United | England |
| 1925 | Charles Sutcliffe | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | Billy Cook | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | Ernest Milton | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | Harry Pantling | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | Seth King | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | George Green | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | David Mercer | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | Tommy Boyle | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | Harry Johnson | Sheffield United | England |
| 1925 | Billy Gillespie (c) | Sheffield United | Northern Ireland |
| 1925 | Fred Tunstall | Sheffield United | England |
| 1926 | Dick Pym | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Bob Haworth | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Harry Greenhalgh | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Harry Nuttall | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Jimmy Seddon | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Billy Jennings | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Billy Butler | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Jack Smith | Bolton Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1926 | David Jack | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Joe Smith (c) | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1926 | Ted Vizard | Bolton Wanderers | Wales |
| 1927 | Tom Farquharson | Cardiff City | Republic of Ireland |
| 1927 | Jimmy Nelson | Cardiff City | Scotland |
| 1927 | Tom Watson | Cardiff City | Northern Ireland |
| 1927 | Fred Keenor (c) | Cardiff City | Wales |
| 1927 | Tom Sloan | Cardiff City | Northern Ireland |
| 1927 | Billy Hardy | Cardiff City | England |
| 1927 | Ernie Curtis | Cardiff City | Wales |
| 1927 | Sam Irving | Cardiff City | Northern Ireland |
| 1927 | Hughie Ferguson | Cardiff City | Scotland |
| 1927 | Len Davies | Cardiff City | Wales |
| 1927 | George McLachlan | Cardiff City | Scotland |
| 1928 | Jock Crawford | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1928 | Jock Hutton | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1928 | Herbert Jones | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1928 | Harry Healless (c) | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1928 | Willie Rankine | Blackburn Rovers | Scotland |
| 1928 | Austen Campbell | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1928 | George Thornewell | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1928 | Syd Puddefoot | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1928 | Jack Roscamp | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1928 | Tommy McLean | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1928 | Arthur Rigby | Blackburn Rovers | England |
| 1929 | Dick Pym | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1929 | Bob Haworth | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1929 | Alex Finney | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1929 | Fred Kean | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1929 | Jimmy Seddon (c) | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1929 | Harry Nuttall | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1929 | Billy Butler | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1929 | Jim McClelland | Bolton Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1929 | Harold Blackmore | Bolton Wanderers | England |
| 1929 | George Gibson | Bolton Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1929 | Willie Cook | Bolton Wanderers | Scotland |
| 1930 | Charlie Preedy | Arsenal | England |
| 1930 | Tom Parker (c) | Arsenal | England |
| 1930 | Eddie Hapgood | Arsenal | England |
| 1930 | Alf Baker | Arsenal | England |
| 1930 | Bill Seddon | Arsenal | England |
| 1930 | Bob John | Arsenal | Wales |
| 1930 | Joe Hulme | Arsenal | England |
| 1930 | David Jack | Arsenal | England |
| 1930 | Jack Lambert | Arsenal | England |
| 1930 | Alex James | Arsenal | Scotland |
| 1930 | Cliff Bastin | Arsenal | England |
| 1931 | Harold Pearson | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | George Shaw | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | Bert Trentham | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | Tommy Magee | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | Bill Richardson | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | Jimmy Edwards | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | Tommy Glidden (c) | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | Joe Carter | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | W. G. Richardson | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | Teddy Sandford | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1931 | Stan Wood | West Bromwich Albion | England |
| 1932 | Albert McInroy | Newcastle United | England |
| 1932 | Jimmy Nelson (c) | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1932 | David Fairhurst | Newcastle United | England |
| 1932 | Roddie MacKenzie | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1932 | Dave Davidson | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1932 | Sam Weaver | Newcastle United | England |
| 1932 | Jimmy Boyd | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1932 | Jimmy Richardson | Newcastle United | England |
| 1932 | Jack Allen | Newcastle United | England |
| 1932 | Harry McMenemy | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1932 | Tommy Lang | Newcastle United | Scotland |
| 1933 | Ted Sagar | Everton | England |
| 1933 | Billy Cook | Everton | Northern Ireland |
| 1933 | Warney Cresswell | Everton | England |
| 1933 | Cliff Britton | Everton | England |
| 1933 | Tommy White | Everton | England |
| 1933 | Jock Thomson | Everton | Scotland |
| 1933 | Albert Geldard | Everton | England |
| 1933 | James Dunn | Everton | Scotland |
| 1933 | Dixie Dean (c) | Everton | England |
| 1933 | Tommy Johnson | Everton | England |
| 1933 | Jimmy Stein | Everton | Scotland |
| 1934 | Frank Swift | Manchester City | England |
| 1934 | Laurie Barnett | Manchester City | England |
| 1934 | Bill Dale | Manchester City | England |
| 1934 | Matt Busby | Manchester City | Scotland |
| 1934 | Sam Cowan (c) | Manchester City | England |
| 1934 | Jackie Bray | Manchester City | England |
| 1934 | Ernie Toseland | Manchester City | England |
| 1934 | Bobby Marshall | Manchester City | England |
| 1934 | Alec Herd | Manchester City | Scotland |
| 1934 | Eric Brook | Manchester City | England |
| 1934 | Fred Tilson | Manchester City | England |
| 1935 | Jack Brown | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1935 | Joe Nibloe | Sheffield Wednesday | Scotland |
| 1935 | Ted Catlin | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1935 | Wilf Sharp | Sheffield Wednesday | Scotland |
| 1935 | Walter Millership | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1935 | Horace Burrows | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1935 | Mark Hooper | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1935 | Jack Surtees | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1935 | Jack Palethorpe | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1935 | Ronnie Starling (c) | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1935 | Ellis Rimmer | Sheffield Wednesday | England |
| 1936 | Alex Wilson | Arsenal | Scotland |
| 1936 | George Male | Arsenal | England |
| 1936 | Eddie Hapgood | Arsenal | England |
| 1936 | Jack Crayston | Arsenal | England |
| 1936 | Herbie Roberts | Arsenal | England |
| 1936 | Wilf Copping | Arsenal | England |
| 1936 | Joe Hulme | Arsenal | England |
| 1936 | Ray Bowden | Arsenal | England |
| 1936 | Ted Drake | Arsenal | England |
| 1936 | Alex James (c) | Arsenal | Scotland |
| 1936 | Cliff Bastin | Arsenal | England |
| 1937 | Johnny Mapson | Sunderland | England |
| 1937 | Jimmy Gorman | Sunderland | England |
| 1937 | Alex Hall | Sunderland | Scotland |
| 1937 | Charlie Thomson | Sunderland | Scotland |
| 1937 | Bert Johnston | Sunderland | Scotland |
| 1937 | Alex 'Sandy' McNab | Sunderland | Scotland |
| 1937 | Len Duns | Sunderland | England |
| 1937 | Raich Carter (c) | Sunderland | England |
| 1937 | Bobby Gurney | Sunderland | England |
| 1937 | Patrick Gallacher | Sunderland | Scotland |
| 1937 | Eddie Burbanks | Sunderland | England |
| 1938 | George Holdcroft | Preston North End | England |
| 1938 | Len Gallimore | Preston North End | England |
| 1938 | Andy Beattie | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1938 | Bill Shankly | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1938 | Tom Smith (c) | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1938 | Bob Batey | Preston North End | England |
| 1938 | Dickie Watmough | Preston North End | England |
| 1938 | George Mutch | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1938 | Bud Maxwell | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1938 | Bobby Beattie | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1938 | Hugh O'Donnell | Preston North End | Scotland |
| 1939 | Harry Walker | Portsmouth | England |
| 1939 | Lew Morgan | Portsmouth | Scotland |
| 1939 | Bill Rochford | Portsmouth | England |
| 1939 | Jimmy Guthrie (c) | Portsmouth | Scotland |
| 1939 | Tommy Rowe | Portsmouth | England |
| 1939 | Guy Wharton | Portsmouth | England |
| 1939 | Fred Worrall | Portsmouth | England |
| 1939 | Jimmy McAlinden | Portsmouth | Northern Ireland |
| 1939 | John Anderson | Portsmouth | Scotland |
| 1939 | Bert Barlow | Portsmouth | England |
| 1939 | Cliff Parker | Portsmouth | England |
