FA Charity Shield Order of Merit 1908-2017  
  Team Wins (Shared)  Runners-Up  
  Manchester United 21 (3) 9  
  Arsenal 15 (1) 7  
  Liverpool 15 (5) 6  
  Everton 9 (1) 2  
  Tottenham Hotspur 7 (3) 2  
  Chelsea 4 7  
  Manchester City 4 5  
  Professionals XI 4 2  
  Wolverhampton Wanderers 4 (3) 2  
  Amateurs XI 2 4  
  Leeds United 2 1  
  Derby County 2 0  
  Burnley 2 (1) 2  
  West Bromwich Albion 2 (1) 2  
  Portsmouth 2 (1) 1  
  Newcastle United 1 5  
  Blackburn Rovers 1 3  
  Charlton Athletic 1 1  
  Leicester City 1 1  
  Nottingham Forest 1 1  
  Sheffield Wednesday 1 1  
  Sunderland 1 1  
  Bolton Wanderers 1 0  
  Brighton & Hove Albion 1 0  
  Cardiff City 1 0  
  England World Cup 1950 XI 1 0  
  Huddersfield Town 1 0  
  Aston Villa 1 (1) 3  
  West Ham United 1 (1) 2  
  Ipswich Town 0 2  
  Queens Park Rangers 0 2  
  Blackpool 0 1  
  Corinthian 0 1  
  Coventry City 0 1  
  FA Canadian Touring Team 0 1  
  FA XI 0 1  
  Northampton Town 0 1  
  Preston North End 0 1  
  Southampton 0 1  
  Swindon Town 0 1  
  Wigan Athletic 0 1  
  Wimbledon 0 1